« Frigidity R.I.P | Main | Saawariya- Two thumbs up :) »
Crushing ‘love’ or Loving ‘crush’?
One casual evening, my 9 plus daughter Shruti asked “Do we really get butterflies in the stomach when we fall in love?”
Butterflies didn’t register that fast to me as was the word Love. I kept cool wondering where it is coming from and then found out the source. She watched high school musical on TV last Sunday where teenage stars are busy loving and discussing chemistry, biology and geography of love. Bit relaxed at the discovery, I resumed to explanation.
I said, “It is not actually the butterflies that enter into our stomach but it is the sweet feelings, anxiety, anticipation and restlessness that love brings along with it is referred to as butterfly.”
“So what is love?” was the next question in my face.
.I needed to explain in her vocabulary what is love? I searched for words quickly and tried to break down complex love into simple words for her.
I said, “Love is feeling good about somebody, wanting to care for someone’s needs, wanting to do things for somebody and also treating the other as your own self and sometimes sacrificing one’s comforts for other’s happiness.” It sounded heavy to me though. I again tried to make it simpler. I said ‘the symptoms of love at times start with getting dress conscious, self-conscious or sometimes impression-conscious and wanting to look at somebody again and again or thinking about someone all the time. But there are further tests to confirm if it is really love or just fake.” (Last note was clearly from the baggage of my upbringing. ‘’Words of caution’’.)
It seemed to click with her level of understanding. But at onset of her 10th year whether she would make out, I wasn’t too sure. Days passed and then came the D-day.
“I am in love”, she declared.
“Who is he?” I asked
“Harry Potter” she replied.
“But he is too old for you,” I wanted to wash him off her mind at first go.
There was a silence. Our eyes met. I did not dare to ask anything further as we both saw “Cheeni Kum” a night before.
Next week a huge cardboard with a Harry potter’s printout neatly pasted was decorating her room. As a woman it was a special moment for me. I truly celebrated the growing girl in her and secretly missed out on not having done so in my childhood. But soon the parent took over. I needed to discuss with her about the crush and love. The sanctity and purity of love in her life should not get mixed with heartaches and breaks of crushes that strengthen you as an individual. She needed to aware of thin lines between loving crushes and crushing loves. But how was a question that needed a preparation from my side.
It was night time and we both were preparing for sleep. Vinay was yet to arrive. I initiated the discussion. “You are a grown up girl now and I can share my secrets with you”, I told her. The word secret evoked the child in her and the grown up girl was left behind. “So child like” I said to myself and smiled. “Please share your secret I will not tell it to anybody”, she assured.
“I also had a crush on a film star when I was your age.” I admitted to her.
“What is crush” she interrupted.
“Crush is something which you are going through right now” I lovingly looked at her saying this. She didn’t want to discuss her own new secret. She was feeling shy. Her coyness and shyness about this new phase of feelings gave such a pure glow on her face that I was touched at the purity of the emotion called love. But to enable her enjoy this pure emotion and to celebrate it in true sense it was important to make her comfortable about this passing phase and discuss with her.
I then explained to her that it is a wonderful phase in her life to have first crush and I do respect her emotions regarding Master Potter. But we should call him “first crush”. I also told her that it is an exciting phase as one learns many things about one’s own self during first crush. So she should not exhaust herself in being very secretive about it rather discuss and enjoy coping this passing phase.
“When will I be in love then?” she enquired.
“After some crushes we are able to experience and identify love on our own. In the beginning the crush seems like love. Even the butterflies get confused. So sometimes people treat crush like love. Since you are an intelligent girl, you can treat it as crush and you’ll slowly develop the sense when it is not the crush but love” I wanted to simplify.
I didn’t know how much she understood but for two months each international film festival we went to, she kept helpdesk girls busy with printouts and information on Harry Potter. She even had cards and letters from her friends who all had crush for Harry Potter’s other friends on each of our foreign visits. After two months the D-day came and she announced.
“I have second crush”,
“Who is that” I was eager.
“Jack and Kody- they are really cute and funny. They are real comedians.”, she was talking about the teenage artists of a new foreign series imported for Indian children on the television.
“So Harry wasn’t really good”, I said.
“Mummy Please don’t say a word against him”, came a curt reply.
“Is it okay that I first liked Harry Potter and now I like Jack and Kody also”, she asked seeking an affirmative answer.
“Yes it is okay to have numbers in crushes. Perhaps that’s why we call them crushes. Slowly when this number game stops and the number doesn’t change for a long, it means we can discuss about love.” She seemed interested. I continued,” As we grow our tastes, habits, likings change and also our role models, favorite heroes/heroines keep changing. But gradually when we mature in body as well as in mind, we get a clear idea of what we like and what we do not like and then our choice of people we want to love also gets clearer.”, I replied.
I am sure she would not forget Harry Potter. Why should she?
Even I remember my first crush. Am I right?
Do send in your own joys...sorrows...on attempt of discussing sex and sexuality with your children.
Posted By Meenakshi and Vinay Rai - 7:09 PM Thursday 18 October 2007
The golden moments of a person's initiation into sex should be the times when the young person sits face to face , not with a prostitute, a sexy TV show or a bawdy movie, with one's own parents. Nothing can ever match that intimate encounter.
Many Asian parents cringe at the thought of their children asking about sex, as though the moment is the most stressful in their years of child-rearing. Such moment should open not just eyes and minds but opportunities for trust, further bonding and care. These are the ingredients that will pull children away from sexual adventurism and early sexploration.
Meenakshi did well in facing the issues squarely, rather than letting surrogate parents (called TV, literature and other media) take over, with disastrous results.
Hats off!
Posted by
Great ! u cud convey the needed so alearly and in such a subtle way..... amazing !! u hav that art of conversation thru which u cud explain the desired to the little one !!!!!!
Posted by
ANAKTV SEAL (Philippines)
by Mag Cruz Hatol
column for 14 September 2008
HEALING VICTIMS OF SEXUAL VIOLENCE
At the Chinh India Forum last month, one session began with the screening of “That Year, That Day”, a riveting video on child sexual abuse. It was a no-nonsense production that brought to its producer-director couple, Meenakshi and Vinay Rai, recognition in India as well as in international competitions. In a capsule, the piece prodded viewers to “wake up to the issue of child abuse”.
It was also appropriate that Jasjit Purewal, an articulate Indian socio-psychologist, discussed not only the film’s merits but the issue of abuse in general, she having been deeply involved with work on women, violence and gender issues for several years. Purewal is a busy woman whose hands are full in another aspect of human care: healing.
In the years of her work in New Delhi, Purewal noticed that what were repeatedly knocking on her clinic door were victims of sexual violence. The percentage vis a vis usual victims of simple gender issues was increasing in time. As a matter of fact, she observed, the figures were the same in whatever class or age. She was becoming convinced that the myth of Asia in general, and India in particular, being “family-oriented” was debunked. She was quick to cite media which have become namby pamby about sexual reportage as an accessory to the general indifference. Resultantly, when it comes to sexuality, discomfort has become a tradition. “If we know our children will be sexual beings, as they have been destined to be, we must prepare them intellectually while they are young. Why are we always silent?” she muses. As proof, there is no existing grammar of sexuality, not in India, not in the Philippines.
It is this indifference that has caused the worldwide child pornography industry to balloon to USD 65 billion. Beijing staged its Olympics at USD 40 billion.
One of the most startling discoveries Purewal made in the course of her study was the inordinate amount of abuse being heaped on boys, at least until they reached puberty. It is assumed that as a boy becomes physically stronger, he finds the gall and balls to fight back. With boys, sexual abuse appeared age-related; with girls it was continuous.
Purewal was aghast that the cases of sexual abuse were not mere phenomena but a reality that was ascending to epidemic proportions. However, that sordid reality was persistently being discussed in backdoor whispers while media was having a heyday trivializing or sensationalizing cases!
“Why was there so much pedophilia?” she wondered. The statistics were so regular in a large land mass, population density and cultural diversity such as India. “It was feeding on a cycle”, she concluded, that if a victim is mentally or emotionally healed from it, “the scars would nevertheless be deep. Healing was possible but the victim remained scarred for life.” Such stark reality surfaced in the Rai film. A number of men, now in their prime years, spoke gallantly about a painful fragment of their childhood but in the recollection, a few of them broke down. The Rais are now inspiredly doing another film, aptly titled, “Memory Becomes a Scar.”
Purewal today works with eunuchs, sex workers, homosexuals as well as men and women who have suffered some form of sexual abuse. Her sessions on child sexual abuse put men and women together and the room becomes genderless. Trust is built and nurtured until the once-victims begin talking about their experiences. From all this openness, Purewal is able to peddle hope. She starts when the victims begin unmasking themselves, holding sacred the very moment in the workshop where innocence should have been preserved. It is where her “healing” process gets down to work.
“Stranger things have been happening these days,” Purewal recounts. “Alarmingly, there are more women who have become sexually addicted and they come to me now to learn control, a part of healing.” She employs a combination of modern psychology with indigenous belief processes. According to the Vedas, man has three meridians, one governed by the body, the other ruled by the mind and the last by the spirit. The second chakra of the body is the sexual chakra, the abode of the self. “It is the self that is cosmic and indestructible”, she clarifies. “Within the cosmic Indian vision, the erotic being or the sexual union is like experiencing the same nirvana energy.”
From a one-stop crisis center, Purewal’s clinic has evolved into a place where police reports are culled, studied and addressed, hence becoming an action center. Later, it has morphed into a healing center. Much of Delhi now sends her women who needed comforting and reassurance after being defiled or beaten up.
Posted by
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
I have recently started visiting this site and this is among one of my early reads.
Hats off to you meenakshi....
The description couldnn't get any closer to a real situation. There is a lot of innocence passing on from your child into your writing; a good piece!